Dr. M.J. Bazos MD,
Patient Handout
Reflex
Sympathetic Dystrophy Syndrome- Myths and Facts
Reflex sympathetic dystrophy syndrome
(RSD) is poorly understood by patients, their families, and healthcare
professionals. In some cases the condition is mild, in some it is moderate, and
in others it is severe. We have compiled a list of some of the common
misconceptions about this syndrome followed by the facts.
MYTH - Reflex Sympathetic Dystrophy
Syndrome (RSD/CRPS) is
rare.
FACT — It is not a
rare disorder and may affect millions of people in this country. This syndrome
occurs after 1 to 2 % of various fractures, after 2 to 5% of peripheral nerve
injuries, and 7 to 35% of prospective studies of Colles fracture. The diagnosis
is often not made early and some of the very mild cases may resolve with no
treatment and others may progress through the stages and become chronic, and
often debilitating.
MYTH - RSD/CRPS
is a recently discovered
disease.
FACT— It was
described during the Civil War and has been in the literature under a variety of
names ever since.
MYTH - RSD/CRPS
does not spread.
FACT —
The usual pattern of spread is up the same extremity and then may continue to
spread on the same side of the body or to the opposite extremity. RSD/CRPS may
spread to a distant site. According to the RSDSA database, the condition
spreads in 70% of patients.
MYTH -
RSD/CRPS will burn itself out in 6
months.
FACT — Many
patients who are not treated early will experience spread of RSD and this may
become a lifelong problem. Even with early treatment this may become a chronic
condition.
MYTH - Children do not
get RSD/CRPS — limb pain in children is
psychological.
FACT —
RSD/CRPS can start as young as 3 years of age. This is not a psychological
condition. Children may develop psychological problems when physicians, parents,
teachers, and other children do not believe their complaints of
pain.
MYTH - Minor injuries cannot
cause RSD/CRPS.
FACT —
Minor injuries, such as a sprain or a fall are frequent causes of RSD/CRPS.
RSD/CRPS can start immediately after the injury or later. One characteristic of
RSD/CRPS is that the pain is more severe than expected for the type of injury
that occurred. In 10 to 26% of cases no precipitating factor can be
found.
MYTH - A painful limb should
be put in a cast.
FACT—
Casting and immobilization can cause worsening of RSD/CRPS symptoms. In some
cases it may be necessary, but great care should be taken. Although not well
studied, available clinical data suggest that immobilizing an injured limb for
an extended period may be a risk factor for developing
RSD/CRPS.
MYTH - After one or two
treatment programs have not helped, there is nothing that can be done. The
patient should be told to go home and learn to live with the
pain.
FACT — There are
many forms of treatment for RSD/CRPS. Treatment may include medication,
sympathetic nerve blocks, physical therapy, psychological support, and possibly
sympathectomy, or dorsal column stimulator. The physician directing the care of
the patient should have a treatment plan. In severe or long term cases, a Pain
Clinic with a coordinated plan may be
helpful.
MYTH - Patients continue to
complain because of secondary gains. They are looking for sympathy and are
gaining satisfaction from this
experience.
FACT— As with
any group of individuals there is a small percentage of RSD/CRPS patients who
get satisfaction from a chronic illness. The vast majority of RSD/CRPS patients
were active, productive individuals prior to this disease and do not enjoy the
pain, the loss of independence, the loss
of
job or inability to attend school and
the loss of income.
The most
devastating aspect of the illness is that physicians, other health care
professionals, employers and especially friends and family members do not
understand how much the patient is suffering. They are not looking for sympathy,
only understanding.
MYTH - Once
RSD/CRPS is in remission, it does not come
back.
FACT — It may
subside for years and then recur with a new injury. The reoccurrence should be
treated immediately.
MYTH - Vigorous
and aggressive physical therapy is
best.
FACT — Physical
therapy should be carried out only under a physician’s supervision.
Osteoporosis occurs with RSD/CRPS and as a result of bone loss, pathological
fractures can be caused by overly aggressive therapy. Additionally,
nerve entrapment and other disorders are sometimes mistakenly diagnosed as
RSD/CRPS. Proper diagnosis should be obtained from a competent
physician.
Physical therapy should be part
of a program of pain control and sympathetic blocks (if indicated).
Mobilization of the affected limb is a very important part of treatment and
should be carried out by a therapist who is familiar with RSD/CRPS. The goal is
to keep the limb moving as much as possible and enable the patient to perform
normal activities. In general, "To hurt, is not to harm" as long as the
patient is self mobilizing. Aquatic therapy at a comfortable water temperature
can often facilitate mobilization of extremities, specially if RSD/CRPS is in
the lower extremity.
However, the
cliché "No pain, no gain" does not apply to RSD/CRPS
patients.
MYTH - The treatment for
all RSD/CRPS patients should be the
same.
FACT — Each patient
needs an individual treatment plan. What helps one patient, may not help
another.
MYTH - RSD/CRPS is not
recognized as a reason for long-term
disability.
FACT — It is.
The physician directing the patient’s care should write a letter or report
describing the severity of the condition and detailing the patient treatment
plan to substantiate the claim. For more information, see the section on Social
Security in our Resource Directory for patients with
RSD.
MYTH - Any physician can treat
RSD/CRPS without outside
help.
FACT — RSD/CRPS is a
complex condition with varying degrees of severity and disability. Patients
should be cared for by a physician who knows how to treat RSD/CRPS. Often, a
team approach (physician, physical therapist, anesthesiologist, mental
health provider, and social worker) is most
helpful.
MYTH - There are no
symptoms except pain, swelling, heat or coldness, and color
change.
FACT — There are
many other symptoms including movement disorders (difficulty starting movement,
increased tone, increased reflexes, tremor, muscle spasms), weakness, fatigue,
skin rashes, frequent infections,
migraine
headaches, and others may be found
as more data is accumulated.
MYTH -
Family and friends find this condition easy to
understand.
FACT —
RSD/CRPS is difficult for many physicians to understand. It is not surprising
that family and friends do not understand the patient’s pain and
disability.
MYTH - The pain is not
as bad as the patient says it
is.
FACT — The pain is
often as bad as claimed and may be even
worse.
MYTH - Blocks and other
treatments only work in the first stage of the
disease.
FACT — There are
treatments that will help in any stage of RSD/CRPS. If RSD/CRPS spreads or if a
new injury occurs, blocks may be effective
again.
MYTH - Narcotics do not help
relieve the pain.
FACT —
Narcotic medications are effective in some patients with RSD/CRPS. This is
always a controversial issue. They are used when non-narcotic pain relievers are
not effective and are used to reduce the level of pain until other forms of
therapy become effective. A formal written contract-protocol between the patient
and physician can help minimize misunderstandings about the potential
complications of narcotic use.
MYTH
- RSD/CRPS occurs in psychologically unbalanced
people.
FACT — Persons who
get RSD/CRPS are not any different than the rest of the population
psychologically. Once they get RSD/CRPS and they are in constant pain they may
be depressed and suffer other psychological changes. When RSD/CRPS symptoms are
relieved these changes
disappear.
MYTH - Every patient has
the same results from a medication or
treatment.
FACT —There are
many forms of treatment and combinations of treatment and medication. What is
highly effective for one, may not work in another. Medication dosages may need
to be adjusted to get the best
results.
MYTH - A patient who has no
visible sign or positive tests does not have
RSD/CRPS.
FACT — RSD/CRPS
is a clinical diagnosis. This means that the physician makes the diagnosis based
on thorough history and physical examination. When seeing a new physician, it is
a good idea to have a brief medical
history
with dates of various treatments
and the response to them. Also include a brief summary of any hospitalizations
and surgeries. It is helpful for the doctor to have a copy of this information
before your appointment. Given the complexity of RSD/CRPS, it is helpful for
the patient to keep their own
et of
relevant medical records.
MYTH -
RSD/CRPS does not occur in
families.
FACT — As we are
accumulating data we are finding families with two or more members with
RSD/CRPS. This is true in about 5% of the
cases.
MYTH - RSD/CRPS following
surgery means that the physician did something
wrong.
FACT — RSD/CRPS can
occur following surgery as well as a rauma. This does not mean that the surgery
was performed incorrectly.
MYTH -
There is no hope for patients who have had RSD/CRPS for a long
time.
FACT — The future of
RSD/CRPS treatment is optomistic. Researchers worldwide investigate effective
treatments and the cause of RSD/CRPS. We hope all physicians will recognize and
diagnose SD/CRPS in the early stages so that the patient can be treated
promptly and appropriately. Any physician unfamiliar with the treatment of
RSD/CRPS should refer patients
immediately
to a physician or center that treats RSD/CRPS.